BHI 3.1·Bulletin
Validation: preliminary
Today's bulletin →
Highest B
§ 09 · ABOUT THE INSTRUMENT

About

The instrument, the author, the governance principles, and how to engage.

§ 01The instrument

The Black Hole Index™ is an open scientific instrument for measuring structural lock-in in digital platforms. It produces a single dimensionless number per platform — the ratio of capture pressure over escape capacity, evaluated across eleven measurable parameters.

The instrument is intentionally minimal. It does not rank value, ethics, regulation, or pricing. It reports the structural fact and leaves interpretation to the reader.

BHI draws on 70 years of economics: CES production functions from Solow (1956), switching cost theory from Farrell and Klemperer (2007), network effects from Katz and Shapiro (1985), increasing returns from Arthur (1989), and status quo bias from Samuelson and Zeckhauser (1988). The combination — a single dimensionless ratio that separates tools from traps — is the contribution.

§ 02The author

Ivan Savich

Ivan Savich — founding author and maintainer of the BHI. Based in Ukraine. Started as an underground electrician in a Donetsk coal mine, earned a Master's in Political Science, moved into banking and reached senior management (80-person team, 9 years in finance). Left everything in 2014 when war came. Started over. Learned to build software from zero — BHI, a 14-language news platform, quantitative trading systems.

§ 03Contact and links

§ 04Governance principles

  1. Reproducibility. The model is deterministic and public — every score recomputes from its eleven parameters. Per-parameter evidence trails do not yet exist: 1 platform of 184 carries a written rationale, and closing that gap is the current work. Methodology is open under CC BY 4.0.
  2. Stability before novelty. The aggregation function is versioned. Changes require documentation and historical score reissuance.
  3. No paid placement. No platform pays to be in, out, or higher in the index. Universe constructed by published criteria.

Public audit log

2026-08-14V3.1Response to the CMA consultation on a proposed steering conduct requirement for Apple’s mobile platform published by the CMA under “Feedback received”, one of 37 non-confidential responses. Publication is not endorsement.
2026-07-05V3.1Q3-2026 quarterly update: 34 score changes across 34 platforms. Agentic-autonomy theme; regulators eased Apple/WhatsApp/EU-stablecoin lock-in. Biggest mover TSMC +1.37.
2026-06-04V3.1Q2-2026 quarterly update: universe expanded to 184 platforms across 18 sectors. 10 score changes. 6 new sectors added.
2026-04-10V3.1Paper submitted to SSRN (Abstract ID 6555158).
2026-04-08V3.1Unsolicited third-party submission to the CMA Call for Evidence on Apple’s and Google’s app store rules; receipt acknowledged by the Digital Markets Unit on 13 April 2026. Not published by the CMA.
2026-03-25V3.0Research-paper cross-section frozen: 100 platforms across 12 sectors (96 platforms at the Q4 2025 launch; 100 from Q1-2026 — corrected 13 Sep 2026).
2026-03-01V3.0Capture/escape/extended split written up for the research paper (V3.0 rubric in production since Q3 2025).
2026-02-15V3.0Interactive calculator (Observatory) launched on blackholeindex.com.
2026-01-20V3.0Rankings page with 12-sector breakdown published.

§ 05Advisory board

The BHI advisory board does not exist. Every seat is open, none has been filled, and no quarterly release or methodology change published by this project has been reviewed by such a board or peer-reviewed by anyone through it. The seats below are a standing open call and nothing more. Corrected 19 September 2026: this paragraph read “The BHI advisory board is currently being formed. Prospective members will review quarterly releases, validate methodology changes, and provide peer review”, which described a body in being and promised a peer review that has not happened. The same claim stood in a stronger form on /governance and is corrected there on the same date; a correction applied to one page and not to the identical claim on another is its own kind of failure, and this project has made that one before.

SEATS OPEN

If you work in industrial organisation, competition policy, quantitative finance, or econometric measurement: ivan.savich@blackholeindex.com

§ 06How to engage

  • Read. Every release ships with methodology, validation, and the working paper. → Paper
  • Probe. The Observatory is a live calculator; score any platform in your browser. → Observatory
  • Collaborate. The inter-rater reliability study is pre-declared, its protocol and cohort frozen by digest before execution; recruitment is deferred, not cancelled. → Contact
WHAT BHI IS
  • A structural lock-in measurement instrument
  • A dimensionless ratio (like Reynolds or Sharpe)
  • Applicable to AI, finance, crypto, SaaS
  • Open methodology, open formula
WHAT BHI IS NOT
  • A product quality score
  • A user satisfaction metric
  • A financial recommendation
  • A prediction of price movements